Buffalo Chicken Pizza!

Just in time for the weekend. Pizza is such a weekend-y food, isn’t it? And this Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a melty, gooey, spicy, tomatoey, crisp-crusted wonder.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

My version is also without sugar, gluten, yeast or (cow) dairy. Let me tell you, it took me long searches and many trials to come up with this, but it was well worth each and every experiment.

Now, don’t be a hater and close out or scroll past. You can make it with gluten and dairy and all of those other things, if you so choose. But for those of you with food sensitivities or who are on a quest for healthier eating, isn’t it good to know you have options?

Here’s what you need.

pizza ingredients

I’ll provide the full ingredient list at the end of this post, but for now, let’s get cooking. First, the crust.

Namaste Pizza Crust Mix

I’ve tried cornmeal crusts that were too heavy. I’ve tried others that were too salty. But this one was ju-u-u-st right! As you can see it’s very allergen free and it has no sugar. (Granted, pizza is pretty carb-heavy, but this is a treat meal – not an every week thing.) Even more importantly, this mix makes a crust that is delicious and crispy!

If you have a pizza stone (which I would highly recommend), put it in the oven and preheat to 450.

Measure out a cup and a half of the pizza crust mix into a medium bowl.

pizza crust mix

Add a cup and a quarter of water.

add water

Add one teaspoon of oil.

my thumb

Yes, I realize that is my thumb and not oil. But, conveniently enough, my thumb makes an indentation that is approximately the size of a teaspoon.

teaspoon of oil

See?  Saves time and having to wash the measuring spoons. Handy trick. You ought to try it.

Beat the mixture with an electric mixer for three minutes. It will have the consistency of cake batter.

pizza "dough"

While the oven continues to preheat, prepare the chicken so that it has a few minutes to marinate. Coat the bottom of a small bowl with Texas Pete Hot Sauce.

Texas Pete

Yee haw!

Cut one pound of chicken into bite-sized pieces.

bite-sized chicken

Here’s another tip: I hate cutting raw meat, but if it’s still slightly frozen, it’s not so slimy and slippery.

Put the chicken in the bowl, add more hot sauce and mix to coat.

coated chicken

Let that sit for ten or fifteen minutes.

Once the oven is preheated, take out the pizza stone and sprinkle with cornmeal.


This helps to prevent sticking and makes the crust even yummier. Learned this from K. (Thanks, K!)

With a rubber spatula, spread your pizza “dough” quickly and evenly, using as much of the stone as possible. It takes some practice, but is completely doable. Just make sure there are no holes!

pizza crust

Pop that in the oven for 20 minutes.

While that is cooking, get your husband to grate some cheese. Just remind him that he needs to lift the grater once in a while so that the cheese doesn’t get all mashed together in one big lump.

goat cheddar

We use goat cheddar, or goat mozzarella if we can find it, but if that doesn’t blow your hair back, use whatever moves you.

Next, heat a non-stick skillet over medium high heat. Dump in the chicken and give it a stir.

buffalo chicken

You just want to sear it. If you cook it too much, it will dry out in the oven. Stir occasionally so that it cooks evenly, but take it off the heat once the sides of the chicken have turned white.

cooked chicken

About like this. (Sorry for the blurry picture. I was trying not to get steam in my camera!)

If I have time left, I prep the olive oil by pouring it into a small bowl or cup – just enough to cover the bottom. I’ll tell you what that’s for later.

olive oil

After 20 minutes, take the pizza stone back out of the oven. Your crust should be golden brown and a bit puffed up.

baked crust


Now for the toppings. First the pizza sauce. I suppose I could make my own. My mom’s got a killer recipe. But let’s be realistic here. We do the best we can with the time we have and the best I can do right now is this:

pizza sauce ingredients

No sugar!

A fairly short ingredient list and I know what every one of these things is. Well, except for “natural flavor”. I’ve never been too clear on that vagueness. If anyone can enlighten me, I’m all ears.

Spoon about one cup of pizza sauce (or about half of a 14 oz jar) onto the crust. Add Texas Pete Hot Sauce according to taste and use a spoon to combine.

pizza sauce

Spread the sauce evenly over the crust.

Sprinkle with grated Romano (or Parmesan) cheese. We use Romano.

Romano cheese

Because it’s made from sheep’s milk, not cow’s.

sprinkled with Romano

I probably use 3 or 4 Tbsp, but I’m Italian. I really don’t measure most things. Sorry about that.

Add the shredded cheese.

shredded cheese

Add the chicken. It’s fine if the Hot Sauce from the pan flows onto the pizza. The more buffalo the better, baby!

add the chicken

Do not skip this next step! Unless you’re weird and don’t like garlic bread. Then it’s okay.

Remember that little bowl of olive oil? Grab that.

brush & olive oil

Brush the olive oil onto the visible crust.

brushing the crust

If there is any left, drizzle it over the rest of the pizza.

Sprinkle your edges with garlic powder.

garlic powder

This will make your crust come out like garlic breadsticks.

garlic crust

I learned that trick from Laurie Loo. (Thanks, Laurie Loo!)

Slide the whole thing into the oven and bake for 12 and a half minutes.

in the oven

In the meantime, I prepare our salads.

simple salad

No meal in this house is ever eaten without a vegetable. Not even weekend pizza.

Once 12 and a half minutes is up, remove the pizza from the oven. It should look something like this:

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Let it cool for five minutes. Then make your husband cut it into slices.

pizza slices


Buffalo Chicken Pizza


  • 1 ½ c. Namaste Pizza Crust Mix
  • 1 ¼ c. water
  • Olive oil
  • 1 lb. chicken
  • Texas Pete Hot Sauce
  • Cornmeal
  • 1 c. pizza sauce
  • Romano or Parmesan Cheese
  • Goat cheddar (about 6 oz.) or other cheese, shredded
  • Garlic Powder


  1. Put pizza stone in oven and preheat to 450 degrees.
  2. In medium bowl, combine pizza crust mix, water and one teaspoon of oil. Beat the mixture with an electric mixer for three minutes. It will have the consistency of cake batter.
  3. Coat the bottom of a small bowl with Texas Pete Hot Sauce. Cut 1 lb. of chicken into bite-size pieces. Put the chicken in the bowl, add more hot sauce and mix to coat. Let sit for ten or fifteen minutes.
  4. Remove pizza stone from preheated oven. Sprinkle stone with cornmeal. With a rubber spatula, spread the pizza “dough” quickly and evenly, using as much of the stone as possible. Make sure there are no holes. Bake for 20 minutes.
  5. Heat a non-stick skillet over medium high heat. Sear the chicken until the sides have turned white. Remove from heat and set aside.
  6. Remove crust from the oven. The crust should be golden brown and a bit puffed up. Spoon about one cup of pizza sauce (or about half of a 14 oz jar) onto the crust. Add Texas Pete Hot Sauce according to taste and use a spoon to combine. Spread the sauce evenly over the crust. Sprinkle with grated Romano (or Parmesan) cheese. Cover with shredded cheese. Add the chicken.
  7. Brush the visible crust with olive oil, then sprinkle with garlic powder.
  8. Bake for 12 and half minutes.
  9. Let cool for five minutes before cutting.
  10. Enjoy!

17 responses to “Buffalo Chicken Pizza!

  1. Um, yum. Not that I feel like cooking tonight, or grocery shopping, or anything, but this is going on my to-be-cooked list. :)

  2. I should try this sometime and see how Derek likes it! See if he even notices its gluten free! It looks great! Thanks for the tips!

    • Let me know what he thinks! You can also use regular pre-made pizza dough – they sell it in the deli section and even have whole wheat – but I would encourage you to try the Namaste. It’s very good.

  3. I’ll be honest….I was totally going to close this, but you said not to, so I read through it and it looks AMAZING! I’m going to add it to my list. Thanks for sharing it!

  4. So glad to find your blog! My husband is obsessed with buffalo chicken anything so this looks good. I might use Daiya (dairy/soy/sugar free cheese). I never knew buffalo flavor was just hot sauce! And love your raised bed- we are doing one this week, too :)

  5. I really like the crust idea! Awesome.

  6. You can Google that “Natural Flavoring” thing, but it is a catch all for all things you don’t want to know about. Everything in the world is natural, just may not all be good for human consumption. Make your mom’s sause and freeze it. Then you won’t have to buy the can/jar (sorry CRAP).

    • If you mean the pizza sauce is CRAP nutritionally, I disagree. It’s made mostly of pureed tomatoes with a few spices. The additives are minimal. If you mean it tastes like CRAP, I also disagree. It’s one of the better brands out there, I’ve found. Not as good as my mom’s, of course, but what is?

  7. therecoveringbrit

    Oh amazing! Mark would love this – I’ll have to try it sometime!

  8. I have tried so many different brands, and nothing taste like homemade (clarify if that person knows how to cook). I just make a bunch and save. Then it is ready when I need it. If you are happy, when you don’t have your mom’s around, that is all that matters. Just my particular preference.

  9. Yum!!! I love buffalo chicken pizza! And I especially love the use of goat cheese! Delicious!!

  10. Pingback: What’s on your menu for the weekend? « …At Your Fingertips

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s